Sovereignty captures the 2025 Kentucky Derby
Sovereignty overcame a tough situation and a competitive field with a win in the rainy 2025 Kentucky Derby at Churchill Downs.
Junior Alvarado, a jockey who took sovereignty towards his victory in the Kentucky Derby on May 3, sparked controversy after the race steward said he used the riding crop above the acceptable limit of six strikes during the race.
Alvarado faces a $62,000 fine and an impressive halt of sovereignty eight times for violating the sovereignty, with a $62,000 fine and two-day sovereignty. It has been violated more than 2,500 times within three years, according to the Horse Racing Integrity and Safety Agency (HISA), which regulates thoroughbred races in the United States.
When Hisa’s RaceTrack Safety Program was launched in July 2022, crop regulations came into effect.
“I’m surprised to see so many of the violations,” said Ramon Dominguez, a retired jockey and 2016 National Race Museum and Hall of Fame. Most jocks certainly follow and want to follow these rules.”
There is another potentially divisive issue in the involvement of sports from reducing public interest and concern about animal welfare. However, industry leaders such as Hisa CEO Lisa Lazarus told USA Today Sports that sovereign teams skip Preakness Stakes and even if they point to Belmont’s betting on June 7th, it’s an opportunity to educate the public.
Lazarus said 90% of violations of the crop rules resulted from the horse attacking the horse seven times.
“I don’t minimize the importance, but it’s essentially a miscant-like jockey and just lose track,” Lazarus told USA Today Sports. “They still broke the rules. We’re still doing that, but we’re looking in one direction in a completely different way than doing one or more (limitations).
Why are crops allowed in horse racing?
Not everyone believes that they need crops.
Sweden and Denmark limit their use for essentially non-safe reasons, and Norway generally does the same.
In 2021, the New Jersey Racing Commission (NJRC) imposed rules allowing crops for safety reasons such as piloting a horse, avoiding interference with another horse or accident. However, starting in July 2022, New Jersey and all other states began operating under HISA rules and regulations that allow crop use.
“Equestrian crops are tools,” said Jockey Mikesmith, who won the Triple Crown in 2018 with Justify. It’s just to get their attention.
“So they’re 1,200 pounds of muscle. And sometimes they just fight back against you, showing them riding crops, or tapping behind them.
Terry Meyocks, president and CEO of Jockeys Guild, said he believes crops are used for safety and are intertwined to encourage horses.
“When you go through a hole at the top of a stretch, you want to use crops to get through that hole, so you want to make sure your horses and riders aren’t injured,” Maeox told USA Today Sports.
But Jerry Bailey, a two-time Kentucky Derby winner, said he doesn’t think the crop is in safe use. “I never have,” Bailey told USA Today Sports.
Bailey is a crop used for safety and encouragement, saying, “This is the mantra that jockeys collectively took when this (the numerical limit on strike) was first implemented a few years ago. And of course, I retired for 20 years, but I had feelings after that.
Crops will also be used during the race. Hisa’s RaceTrack Safety Program Rule Book provides details such as:
“Riders must either place the jockey’s wrists on the Knight’s Hospital helmet when using crops to raise the crop, or not use crops on any part of the horse’s body except the shoulders or the dorsal horns. Riders must also use crops only on the rear square or shoulder to activate and focus the horse.
What did Junior Alvarado say?
Alvarado, 38, did not respond to messages left for his wife and agents in a sports message on USA Today, but made a comment on a podcast hosted by Louisville Courier Journal columnist Cl Brown.
Alvarado said he didn’t think about how many times he had sovereignty he had during the race. He also said, “I forgot that was the rule.”
“I was watching my dream come true right in front of my eyes,” he added.
Alvarado’s agents show that the jockey will appeal to disciplinary action.
“I just want to get through it and put it behind me. I don’t want to carry this extra day of the day, but at the same time, I don’t want to give up on it easily as they’re right,” Alvarado told Daily Race Form last weekend.
“I want to move forward and fix something. The penalties we face are unfair, so everyone can see. Maybe (by sue) we can get something good from this.”
He also told the daily race form, “I didn’t abuse the horses. No one can tell me. Even if they hit me twice, it was just absurd, even if it was an abusive way. The punishment doesn’t suit the crime, and I think there was no crime.”
Hisa’s steward director, Mark Guilfoil, asserts that Alvarado did not abuse his whip and sovereignty.
“The horse was not hurt,” Guilfoyle said. “Junior Alvarado is a great rider and a good guy. But he broke the rules, so we’re enforcing the results of that rule.”
Do crops hurt horses?
Rick Arthur, a former California medical director, is working on the issue of whether crops are hurting horses in 2019, speaking at the 53rd Horse Racing Authority Conference in Paris.
“There are people who argue that whipping won’t hurt, but that’s nonsense and we all know that,” Arthur said at the time. “Whips are harmful stimuli. They hurt. That’s why they’re used. They run faster or hit you again. More importantly, in sports that rely on public support, whiplash just looks abusive.”
This week, Arthur told USA Today Sports that the visible welt and cuts given to crops have been reduced by 80% based on systematic post-race testing that began in California about 15 years ago, and advances in crop technology have dropped those injuries to “almost nil.”
Despite advances in crop technology, Arthur said he believes crops should be used only for safety reasons.
Industry Lazarus and others are welcoming new crops as game-changers.
“The material we use in our crops now is very light,” she said. They are very unlikely to hurt the horse.”
All crop models have been tested by Susan Stober, professor emeritus in surgery and radiation science at the University of California Davis School of Veterinary Medicine. Above all, Stober sees that she sees the rigidity of the crop and “to make sure it’s not too stiff… it’s more likely to injure the horse.”
Eight crop models have been approved for Hisa’s use, according to Ann McGovern, director of Racetrack Safety at Hisa. In a statement provided to USA Today Sports, McGovern said before Hisa Enforcement began, “Because bootleggers in some regions made crops, some riders prefer thicker handles, longer shafts and more stringent materials.”
Dominguez, a retired jockey, produces HISA-approved 360 Gentle Touch (360 GT) riding crops. He said that in 2007, crops used in the US began to evolve.
“The difference is from 2007 today’s lunchtime and lunchtime,” he said.
Crop controversy creates gaps
Between the first quarter of 2023 and the first quarter of this year, HISA said crop violations fell by 6%.
It may raise questions about whether disciplinary action serves as an effective deterrent. However, the $62,000 fine imposed on Alvarado sparked rage from the Jockey Guild, representing thoroughbreds and quarter horse riders.
“This is ridiculous,” Jockey Guild’s Mayox was posted on his X account on May 9th.
“There was definitely a meaningful gap between the public’s reaction and the people who have been racing for a long time. … The public’s response was very positive in that Hisa saw it as serious,” Lazarus said.
Hisa’s rules required Alvarado to be fined 10% of a portion of his prize money from his wallet. $31,000 out of his $310,000. Alvarado violated another crop rule within 180 days of the Kentucky Derby, resulting in double the fine.
It could have been even worse for Alvarado, who won the Kentucky Derby for the first time. If he had attacked the horse twice more, sovereignty would have been disqualified from race, based on Hisa’s rules.
Alvarado plans to offer a two-day suspension from May 29th to 30th. He must appeal by the end of Monday, 10 days after the steward meets with Alvarado and issue an order of his violation.
According to the HISA website, Alvarado, ranked sixth among the major riders based on wallet money, has nine crop rules violations. According to Hisa’s website, the top 10 other riders have no more than five violations.
However, Tyler Gaffarion, ranked 16th, has 19 violations, while Francisco Arieta, ranked 14th, has 20 violations. According to Hisa’s website, slightly more than 3.4% of riders have violated crop rules.
The seven violations of Alvarado were seven strikes that exceeded one limit, and the eighth violation was one or three times above the limit, according to records on Hisa’s website.
When crop changes begin
In 2007, British jockeys had to use newly developed padded whips. These whips went down the road towards us, and the tracks and changes began. Meyocks said that recalls the Jockey Club safety meeting attended with Jockey Chris McCarron from the Hall of Fame, which included a push calling the crop a whip.
“Chris said he was basically able to change the terminology and we were talking about perception,” Majox said. Why is it okay to use the term whipping a horse with a horse? We changed it to a riding crop.”
When talking about the restrictions on crop strikes, Guilfoyle cited Victor Espinoza’s winning ride with the American Pharaohs in the 2015 Kentucky Derby.
“I worked for the Kentucky Horse Racing Board. The American pharaohs got off the stretch and hit 28-32 times, depending on how you count,” Gilfiol told USA Today Sports. …So we know, I know, the horses were not abused.
“But someone is there with your family and they see the horse being attacked 32 times. If I’ve always done it to people, you’re going to be in jail.”
“Problems of opinion”
Bailey was a seven-time Eclipse award winner for outstanding rider, and said that Alvarado had a “great” ride in the Kentucky Derby and did a good job away from the trouble.
“I am fully aware of the feelings of with whip from groups across the country, especially PETA,” Bailey said. I feel the same way. But I’ve said this from the beginning. Counting the number of times you use riding crops in any race is really, really, if not impossible, not a race like the Kentucky Derby. That’s really difficult.”
But he also said he supports rules that restrict strikes.
“I really understand the reason behind it and I think our sport has been better in Hisa,” Bailey said.
Someone else who still stands behind the rules: Bill Mott, training sovereignty. He said he saw dozens of race replays and saw Alvarado attack the horse only six times.
“I think that’s really a matter of opinion,” Mott said.
Contribution: Clouds
151st Kentucky Derby Page Print
