Taiwan, Taiwan
–
Taiwan is in the midst of feeling like a full swing election – a giant yellow truck decorated with bears broadcasting emotional gatherings featuring rock bands, and a rival political camp competing for support outside the metro station.
But this passionate political theatre is not about electing lawmakers. Instead, it is an attempt to exclude them using the unusual Quirk of Taiwan’s democratic institutions, namely recall voting.
This Saturday, Taiwan will go to the ballot box to decide whether 24 lawmakers (about 20% of Taiwan’s parliament) from major opposition Kuo Mintan (KMT) can continue their work. There are 7 more seats I’ll be voted next month.
The results could reconstruct Taiwan’s political landscape, allowing the ruling Democrats’ Progressive Party (DPP) to recapture a majority in Congress.
Taiwan’s President Lai Qingte, who has struggled to get his agenda through Congress, supported the recall as he attempts to maintain ties with the US and counter the rising threat from China.
Here’s what you need to know about this massive political showdown
Taiwan’s constitution allows lawmakers to be placed on recall votes After the first year of office, if at least 10% of registered voters in a district signed the petition. It’s a system that makes recalls very common, but this is a record number of recalls on the island.
Supporters of the recall movement are trying to portray their campaign as “anti-communists” and remove “pro-country” KMT lawmakers whom they recognize as collaborators of Beijing’s ruling Communist Party.
They say the opposition has undermined democratic institutions and national security by blocking Lai’s administration, strong controversial laws, frozen defense spending and imposed budget cuts.
They also accused the KMT of quietly “conspired” with Beijing, citing, for example, a meeting between the KMT parliamentary delegation and China’s top official, Wang Huning, in April last year, on the Taiwan issue.
But campaigners provide little difficult evidence. One KMT lawmaker facing a recall is being investigated for allegedly receiving Chinese funds, but the incumbent has not been charged with a national security crime.
KMT rejected these charges, accusing the recall of Taiwan’s democratic rules of abuse, claiming it was an attempt at power grab.
At this month’s rally, KMT president Eric Chu called President Lai a “dictator.”
“The recalls are totally unconstitutional and undemocratic,” said Andrew Hayer, Vice-Chair of KMT. “It’s important that democracy maintains checks and balance.”
At the heart of this political fraca is two competing visions of Taiwan, the island and China.
The ruling DPP party is openly hated by Beijing and has blocked all official communications with Taipei since they took office. The DPP views Taiwan separately from China, and believes it has been a success in general elections in recent years, especially among younger voters.
KMT likes a warm relationship with Beijing and considers Taiwan to be part of “one China,” but both sides agreed to oppose the meaning of China. China’s Communist leadership is much more willing to talk to KMT.
The outcome of the recall will determine whether LAI and his ruling DPP can implement policies that will enhance US support, or whether he will become the president of Lame Duck, who cannot accomplish much.
Taiwan is paralyzed by political shaking, and parliamentary disagreements are sometimes turned into brawls, hampering Lai’s ability to promote agenda items, including those addressing important concerns about Taiwan.
To alleviate concerns about Washington’s security costs, Lai announced that Taiwan will increase its defense spending from 2.5% to more than 3% of its gross domestic product. However, his lack of a majority in Congress may complicate efforts to achieve that.
Lev Nachman, a professor of political science at National Taiwan University, says the outcome of the recall will have a major impact on what Lai can do.
“Most importantly, this includes the issue of defense spending and how U.S. Thailand-wan relations will progress,” Nachman told CNN.
KMT has long maintained to support Taiwan’s improved defensive capabilities, but it insisted that caution should reduce waste and ensure the effectiveness of the weapons program.
Our relationship with China
In recent years, China has been increasing military, diplomatic and economic pressure on Taiwan, sending fighter jets and warships around the island almost every day, trying to narrow its presence on the world stage.
The recall vote shows Taiwan is making a fair share to boost its defense against increasingly offensive China and openly pay US support to the Trump administration.
The US and other Western countries are increasingly concerned about whether Chinese leader Xi Jinping’s vow to “reunite” Taiwan could one day lead to a catastrophic invasion.
The Trump administration’s leading Chinese Hawks, including US Secretary of Defense Pete Hegses and Vice President JD Vance, have urged Washington to spend less time and resources in Europe and instead focus on fighting Asian China.
However, the Trump administration is also urging all Asian allies and supporters to pay more for US protection.
The recall results could also affect Rye’s position with the Trump administration during a highly anticipated and sensitive transport halt in the US next month.
“If the recall is a flop and the DPP is successful, the KMT will be very empowered and President Rye will not be that strong on these transit tours,” Nachman said.
President Lai’s DPP party now controls 51 seats in Taiwan’s 113-seat parliament to just 51.
If KMT lawmakers lose their seat, they must hold the by-election within three months. The DPP may then provide an opening to regain enough seats to regain a majority of the Congress.
The DPP must win at least six seats in the by-election to meet the 57-seat majority threshold.
But if they expel sufficient lawmakers (12), they can quickly win a majority, even before the by-election occurs.
If the recall is successful, LAI will empower you.
“He feels he has an obligation to promote his policy agenda in any way he thinks it is appropriate,” Nuckman added.
Will Ripley from CNN contributed to the report
