Dana Santas,Mobility Makeris a certified strength and conditioning expert in professional sports, mental and physical coach, and is the author of the book “Practical Solutions for Relieving Back Pain.”
That persistent tension in your back, hips and shoulders doesn’t seem to be completely resolved even after stretching before and after workouts, rolling foam, or regular visits to a massage therapist.
In fact, tension can get worse after stretching. If this situation sounds familiar, your body may not just be tight – it may protect itself through involuntary muscle contractions.
Recognizing the distinction between mechanical and protective tension is important for those experiencing the benefits of chronic stiffness, repeated pain, or simply short-term mobility that does not stick.
Understand your body protection system
Your nervous system will constantly monitor your body for potential threats, not just external dangers, but also internal instability and areas of weakness and injury. When the body detects risks of physical function, it responds by creating protective tensions to limit movement in vulnerable areas.
This protective response can be caused by a variety of factors: patterns of posture or movement that cause inconsistencies, chronic stress that keeps your body in a reinforced state of vigilance, joint instability that makes your nervous system feel unsafe, or past injuries that are not completely healed. Unlike simple mechanical muscle tone due to overuse, protective tension is your body’s attempt to generate stability where it perceives a lack of it.
As a professional sports mobility coach, I always rate my clients so that I don’t overlook areas where protective tensions exist. It is important to acknowledge and deal with it as soon as possible to avoid counterproductive effects. Otherwise, what starts as a useful protection can evolve into chronic tension that restricts movement, causes pain, and resists traditional stretching and soft tissue release techniques such as massage and foam rolling.
How can you know if your stiffness is protective rather than mechanical?
There are four main indicators in my experience.
1. Areas that make you feel sick after stretching It’s a big red flag. If you consistently stretch tight areas on your back or neck just to experience a fleeting relief that gives way to increase your painful limits, your nervous system may be responding to what is perceived as a threat by being further protected.
2. Tension on one side that does not respond Bilateral stretching can demonstrate a protective response. For example, if you are tense, even though only the right hip flexors extend equally on both sides, your nervous system may be protecting that particular area for reasons.
3. Repeated tension in the same area Despite consistent stretching, another powerful indicator. If you’re doing regular hamstring stretches for months without long-lasting improvements, the problem may be that the length of your muscles is not the protection of your nervous system.
4. Dramatically changing painful stiffness Intensities based on stress levels also suggest protection guards. Basic mechanical tension occurs directly correlated with physical activity and is alleviated within a few days. In contrast, protective tension is more chronic and fluctuates in the overall nervous system state.
If you are aware of any of these potential symptoms of your own protective tension, consult your doctor to determine if there are underlying injuries or other pathological issues requiring additional treatment..
If you have protective tension, remember that it is not strictly a muscle condition, but a nervous system response. You cannot simply “stretch” the muscles that have been impacted. In many cases, traditional stretching can actually promote tightness by forcing deep muscle extension, resulting in a threat to the nervous system.
A gentler, more inclusive mental and physical approach that addresses the overall nervous system state is necessary to help your body feel safe enough to let go, so that your body can start working to reestablish healthy patterns of movement.
Regular practices that promote nervous system regulation, such as breathing exercises, meditation, and walking around the natural world, help reduce stress levels and let go of patterns that the body is being protected.
Core stability and postural control play an important role in helping the nervous system feel safe. A strong, stable core helps provide the foundation the nervous system needs to allow mobility in other regions. If deep stabilizing muscles are not doing their job effectively, the nervous system can cause tension in other areas.
Sleep quality directly affects the sensitivity of the nervous system threat detection. Deprived sleep can make your nervous system more reactive, and even in response to normal daily activities, it increases protective tension.
For best results, we work with a physical therapist or qualified trainer who is well versed in protective tensions to determine the most appropriate corrective exercise for your specific needs.
Before attempting a mobility task, spend several minutes focusing on deep rhythmic breathing, downregulating the nervous system and shifting it to a more receptive state.
Practice a 5-7-3 breathing pattern to relieve stress from 5 to 6 rounds: 5 counts, 7 exhale, and pause with 3 counts before the next breath.
Your breathing directly affects your nervous system: slow, controlled breathing shows safety and places you in a parasympathetic “rest and return” state, while quick, shallow breathing can cause an empathetic “fighting and flying” state, triggering more security.
Try to maintain slow, deep, conscious breathing while stretching or mobility training. Instead of pushing into the end range, start with gentle, controlled movements that stay within a comfortable range of motion. This approach prevents the nervous system from sounding an alarm, indicating that movements are safe and controllable, not forced or aggressive.
To create lasting results, combine mobility work with strength training for stability. Protective tensions often exist because your nervous system does not trust that the joints and areas are strong or stable enough to handle the demands placed on it. By improving strength and control, it builds the stability your body needs to feel supported.
Finally, prioritize proper rest and recovery. The well-set nervous system releases a guarding mechanism, allowing for functional movement.
Your body’s protective response is not a barrier to overcome. They are intelligent communication about what your internal systems need to be secure and function optimally. When you respect this wisdom, you are laying the foundation for sustainable mobility and pain relief.
Sign up for CNN fitness, but a better newsletter series. Our seven-part guide will help you facilitate a healthy routine that is supported by experts.
